As a rising regional power, India finds itself surrounded by a cauldron of instability in South Asia. The political turbulence and economic crises in Bangladesh, Maldives, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Pakistan, and Afghanistan have far-reaching implications for India's economy. The growing influence of China in these unstable nations adds another layer of complexity, forcing India to navigate a challenging geopolitical landscape. This paper delves into the impact of this unstable neighbourhood on the Indian economy, highlighting the economic repercussions and strategic responses required to safeguard India's interests.
Bangladesh
Political Instability and Economic Implications
The political landscape in Bangladesh has taken a dramatic turn with a military coup, adding to the already volatile situation. The military takeover has resulted in a suspension of civilian governance, triggering widespread protests and international condemnation. The coup exacerbates existing political instability, further jeopardising economic relations and projects between India and Bangladesh. This unexpected upheaval adds another layer of complexity to India's strategic calculations, compelling India to reassess its diplomatic and economic strategies to safeguard its interests amidst the growing uncertainty.
India's trade with Bangladesh, which stands more than $10 billion annually, faces significant uncertainties. Political unrest hampers the progress of cross-border infrastructure projects like the BBIN (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal) initiative, crucial for enhancing regional connectivity and economic integration.
Maldives
Political Turbulence
The Maldives, a strategic island nation in the Indian Ocean, has seen frequent political upheavals and shifts in government. Such instability threatens India's maritime security and influence in the region. Political turmoil in the Maldives also disrupts tourism, a vital sector for bilateral economic relations. The instability forces India to remain vigilant, ready to engage diplomatically and economically to maintain its foothold in the Indian Ocean region.
Myanmar
Civil Conflict
Myanmar's prolonged civil conflict and the military coup in 2021 have destabilized the region, affecting India's economic interests. The ambitious India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway and the Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project, designed to enhance connectivity and trade, face significant delays and uncertainties. The instability in Myanmar complicates India's strategic and economic aspirations in Southeast Asia, necessitating careful navigation of regional dynamics.
Sri Lanka
Economic Collapse
Sri Lanka's economic crisis, characterized by debt defaults and severe financial mismanagement, has profound implications for India. The collapse affects bilateral trade, investment, and the welfare of Tamil Nadu’s fishing communities, closely linked to Sri Lanka. India's exports to Sri Lanka, valued at approximately $4.5 billion annually, are severely disrupted. The economic collapse in Sri Lanka underscores the fragility of regional economic relations and the need for robust economic strategies to mitigate such risks.
Nepal
Political Instability
Nepal's frequent political changes and internal strife directly affect India-Nepal economic relations. Trade, investment, and hydroelectric projects face uncertainties due to political volatility. India’s investments in Nepal, amounting to around $500 million in various sectors, are at risk. The political instability in Nepal highlights the challenges of maintaining stable economic relations with a volatile neighbour and the importance of strategic economic engagement.
Pakistan
Persistent Conflict
India-Pakistan relations are marred by longstanding conflicts, including territorial disputes and cross-border terrorism. These tensions lead to significant defence expenditures, diverting resources from economic development. India spends approximately 2.9% of its GDP on defence, a substantial portion of which is driven by the need to counter threats from Pakistan. The persistent conflict impedes economic cooperation and trade, which remain largely untapped due to political hostility.
Afghanistan
Post-Taliban Uncertainty
The instability in Afghanistan, particularly after the Taliban's resurgence, has significant security and economic implications for India. The volatile situation disrupts regional trade routes and projects such as the Chabahar port in Iran, which India uses to access Central Asia, bypassing Pakistan. India has invested over $3 billion in various reconstruction projects in Afghanistan, efforts now jeopardized by the uncertain political landscape. The instability in Afghanistan underscores the complexities of regional economic engagement in a volatile geopolitical environment.
Democratic Downturn in South Asia: India as the Beacon
South Asia, with its diverse cultures and histories, has largely struggled with the experiment of democracy. Many countries in the region have seen their democratic aspirations falter due to political violence, military coups, authoritarian tendencies, and corruption. These democratic setbacks have led to significant political instability, which in turn has created economic challenges. Frequent government changes, policy inconsistencies, and lack of public trust in democratic institutions have hampered economic growth and development across the region.
In contrast, India stands as a beacon of democratic resilience amidst this backdrop. Despite facing its own challenges, India has maintained a robust democratic framework that attracts foreign investment and fosters economic growth. India’s democratic stability provides a stable environment for economic activities and bilateral relations, offering a reliable partner in an otherwise volatile region. The failure of democracy in neighbouring countries exacerbates their economic instability, thereby impacting India through disrupted trade routes, decreased investment opportunities, and the need for increased diplomatic and economic aid. India's role as a stable democracy in South Asia underscores the importance of democratic governance in achieving economic stability and growth.
The China Factor
China's expanding influence in South Asia through the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and strategic investments poses a multifaceted challenge to India. China's infrastructure projects create significant debt dependencies among South Asian nations, enabling China to exert considerable influence over these countries' economic and political decisions. This strategic encirclement through the "String of Pearls" strategy, involving the development of ports and infrastructure in South Asian countries, compels India to invest heavily in its own strategic infrastructure and defence capabilities, diverting funds from economic development. For example, China’s investment of $62 billion in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) significantly alters the regional economic dynamics. India’s response involves increased economic aid, investments, and diplomatic efforts to maintain stability and counterbalance China’s influence, straining India’s economic resources.
Impact on the Indian Economy
Defence Expenditures
India’s defence budget has seen significant increases due to regional instability and the need to counter China's strategic encirclement. High defence spending, currently at approximately $76.6 billion, diverts funds from crucial economic sectors such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure development, affecting overall economic growth. This figure represents about 15% of the total central government expenditure and is second only to the allocations for social services and public welfare.
Trade Disruptions
Political instability and conflict in neighbouring countries disrupt trade routes and bilateral economic relations. For instance, conflicts in Pakistan and Afghanistan hinder India's trade connectivity to Central Asia, while instability in Myanmar affects trade with Southeast Asia. These disruptions impede economic growth and regional integration efforts. India's trade with South Asia, valued at over $25 billion annually, is at risk due to these instabilities. Additionally, disruptions in trade routes can increase the cost of goods, impacting the Indian consumer and business sectors. The India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway, for instance, which aims to connect India's northeast with Southeast Asia, faces delays due to Myanmar's political situation, potentially delaying economic benefits estimated at over $50 billion in regional trade.
Investment Diversions
India’s need to counter Chinese influence and maintain stability in the region necessitates significant investments in neighbouring countries. This diverts funds from domestic economic development projects, affecting long-term economic growth. India’s aid to neighbouring countries, which amounts to over $2 billion annually, strains its economic resources. For instance, India's development assistance to Afghanistan, including significant investments in infrastructure, education, and healthcare, totals around $3 billion. These funds, while fostering regional stability, are resources that could be utilized for domestic economic projects.
Diplomatic and Economic Aid
India’s efforts to maintain influence in its neighbourhood involve substantial diplomatic and economic aid to unstable countries. This aid, aimed at stabilizing these countries and countering China’s influence, strains India’s economic resources. India’s total foreign aid budget, which includes significant allocations to neighbouring countries, is around $1.6 billion annually. For example, India's aid to Nepal includes investments in infrastructure projects like road construction and hydropower, critical for bilateral relations but also a considerable economic commitment. In Sri Lanka, India provided $900 million in emergency assistance in 2022 to help stabilize its economy, demonstrating the significant financial commitments involved in maintaining regional stability.
Conclusion
The instability in India's neighbourhood, compounded by China's strategic manoeuvres, significantly impacts the Indian economy. Political turmoil, conflicts, and economic dependencies in neighbouring countries necessitate increased defence spending, diplomatic efforts, and economic aid from India. These challenges divert resources from domestic economic development, affecting long-term growth. To mitigate these impacts, India must adopt a multi-faceted approach involving strategic economic investments, enhanced regional cooperation, and robust diplomatic engagements to ensure stability and counterbalance China’s influence in South Asia. By navigating this complex geopolitical landscape with strategic foresight, India can protect its economic interests and maintain its trajectory as a rising regional power.
Authored By
Mr. Amey Velangi
Senior Researcher, The Geojuristoday
Comments